“Education reform” is a term used frequently and freely. We hear it in political campaigns, in school board discussions, and in media coverage of anything related to education.
But what does “education reform” mean?
Simply put, it encompasses a variety of efforts aimed at improving learning outcomes in schools. These efforts seek to address systemic issues within the education system to ensure that all students, regardless of their background or socioeconomic situation, have access to high-quality learning.
There is ever-changing debate surrounding what content makes learning high-quality. But the focus remains constant: education reform means continually improving schools to create educated individuals and an educated society. Education reform directly impacts our society’s future minds and aims to provide our children with vital skills and knowledge.
In this comprehensive overview, we will cover the history of education reform in the United States, the key components of education reform and its significance and impact.
History of Education Reform in the United States
Public education in the United States precedes both the Ivy League and the Declaration of Independence.
The first public school, Boston Latin School, was established in 1635. This was followed by the founding of Harvard College in 1636, nearly 150 years before the Declaration of Independence.
Education in the United States has evolved significantly from its early colonial days. Initially, education was informal and often conducted at home or through small community schools with a focus on religious instruction. Over the years, the U.S. education system has continuously adapted to societal changes, technological advancements, and shifting educational philosophies, leading to the diverse and complex system we see today.
Early Efforts
This all begins with a man whose name is still affixed to dozens of schools around the country: Horace Mann.
Mann, often referred to as “the Father of American Education,” spearheaded 19th century efforts to establish a more structured and universally accessible education system. The programs he designed were initially implemented in Massachusetts and, following the Civil War, spread quickly across the country. Mann’s advocacy for education reform and his emphasis on professional training for teachers laid the groundwork for our current system. His belief in education as a tool for social equality resonated, leading to the establishment of tax-funded public schools.
The Progressive Era in the late 19th and early 20th centuries marked a significant period of education reform in America. The federal government began its involvement by creating The Office of Education in 1867. This organization did not directly impact the curriculum in public schools — but became a center for statistical information on the growing number of American educational institutions. Individual states determined curriculum requirements, and the Office of Education standardized and tracked education reform throughout the country. Thus, the Office supported improvement in education standards but remained unable to enforce policies.1
Reformers like John Dewey championed the idea of experiential learning, emphasizing the importance of teaching students how to think critically and solve problems rather than simply memorizing facts. This period also saw the introduction of child labor laws and compulsory education, ensuring that children had the opportunity to attend school.
The mid-20th century brought about further changes in education, driven by a post-World War II era of economic growth and social change. The Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s played a crucial role in education reform as activists fought for desegregation and equal access to education for all races. The Brown v. Board of Education case ended racial segregation in public schools. This historic win advanced the idea that all students, regardless of race or economic status, deserve access to high-quality schooling. More landmark legislation such as the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) of 1965 aimed to reduce educational disparities by providing federal funding to schools serving low-income students.
Recent Efforts
Teaching standards. Standardized testing. Today, the word “standards” is tightly associated with education reform.
In more recent years there have been efforts focused on aiding disadvantaged students and holding schools accountable for their success. President George W. Bush signed The No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) in 2001.2 The legislation focused on areas in which students needed support as well as where they were succeeding. While the NCLB brought some successes, the act did face criticism for overemphasizing standardized testing, narrowing educational experiences, and pushing teachers to “teach to the test.”
Common Core State Standards launched in 2009, re-addressing teaching standards federally. These standards set out the skills students should have at each grade level and broader expectations of what teachers and education officials should include in curricula. By 2011, all but four states had adopted these learning goals in English/language arts and mathematics.3
In 2015, NCLB was replaced by Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) giving more control back to states and schools.4 This new law provided schools access to more funding, gave disadvantaged schools more resources to help their students and teachers and widened the scope of student success beyond just test scores.
Key Components of Education Reform
Seeing the full scope of education reform demands an understanding of a range of goals. Key components of education reform include curriculum standards, teacher development, school choice, assessments and school accountability, and technology integration.
Let’s dive deeper into each of these components to understand their significance and impact.
Curriculum and Standards
One of the primary focuses of education reform is the development and implementation of rigorous academic standards and curricula. Educational standards aim to ensure that all students, regardless of race, gender, or socioeconomic status, have access to high-quality schools. Curriculum standards set clear expectations for what students learn and skills they should have at each grade level. It helps bridge gaps between varying schools and districts ensuring that all students have access to a quality education no matter where they live.
The development of curriculum standards is a collaborative process involving a wide range of stakeholders — including educators, policymakers, subject matter experts, and community members. This inclusive approach helps to create standards that are relevant and challenging, reflecting current and future student needs. For instance, the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) were developed to provide clear, consistent learning goals in math and English.
While curriculum standards are essential, they are not without their challenges and criticisms. One major concern is that strict adherence to standardized curricula can limit teacher creativity and flexibility, leading to a more uniform and less personalized education. (Check out our deep dive into holistic education for more on this.) Implementing new standards also often requires significant investments in teacher training, instructional materials, and classroom resources. For underfunded schools and districts, this can be an insurmountable added burden. Finding a balance between maintaining high standards and allowing for local flexibility is a key challenge in curriculum reform.
Teacher Development
Skilled teachers lead to successful schools and students.
Education reform efforts often include initiatives to improve teacher training, professional development, and evaluation systems. Programs like Teach for America and various alternative certification routes have been developed to attract and retain talented individuals in the teaching profession.
Teachers play a crucial role in the success of education reform. Their skills, knowledge, and dedication directly impact student learning and achievement. Therefore, investing in teacher development is essential. Well-trained and supported teachers can make a significant difference in students’ educational outcomes.
Professional development for teachers can take various forms, such as workshops, conferences, online courses, and in-service training sessions. These programs aim to enhance teachers’ content knowledge, pedagogical skills, and classroom management techniques. Continuous professional development is vital for helping teachers stay current with best practices, new technologies and evolving educational standards.
Teacher evaluations are critical for creating an environment of ongoing improvement. Effective evaluation systems provide constructive feedback that helps teachers identify areas for improvement and professional growth. These systems often include multiple measures, such as classroom observations, student achievement data and self-assessments. Importantly, evaluations should be accompanied by adequate support, including mentoring, coaching, and access to resources that enable teachers to succeed.
The education system is facing a significant challenge with teacher shortages in many regions. Addressing these shortages requires comprehensive strategies, such as offering competitive salaries, improving working conditions, and providing pathways for career advancement. Initiatives like alternative certification programs and teacher residency models can help attract and retain talented individuals in the teaching profession. (Check out our deep dive into teacher burnout for more information.)
School Choice
The idea behind school choice is simple: parents should be able to choose the best schools for their child.
In reality, school choice is complex, multifaceted and sometimes controversial. It encompasses policies that allow parents to choose the educational setting for their children — traditional public school, charter, private, or home-based.
This concept includes diverse options, such as charter schools, voucher programs, magnet schools, and open enrollment in public schools. The goal is to foster competition among schools, drive innovation, and provide families with alternatives to traditional public schools.
Charter schools are publicly funded but operate independently of the traditional public school system. They have the freedom to design their curricula, set their own policies, and employ innovative teaching methods. This autonomy allows charter schools to experiment with new educational models and tailor their programs to the specific needs of their student populations. However, charter schools are also held accountable for student performance and must demonstrate academic success to remain operational.
Voucher programs provide families with public funding to attend private schools. These programs aim to give low-income families access to educational opportunities that may otherwise be out of reach. Proponents argue that vouchers promote equity by giving all students the chance to attend high-quality schools, regardless of socioeconomic status. Critics, however, contend that voucher programs divert funds from public schools, potentially undermining the public education system. Magnet schools are public schools with specialized curricula or programs, such as STEM (science, technology, engineering, and math), arts, or international studies. These schools attract a diverse student body and provide unique educational opportunities often unavailable in traditional public schools.5 Open enrollment policies allow students to attend public schools outside their designated attendance zones, providing families with more options and fostering competition among schools.
While school choice offers many potential benefits, it also presents challenges. Ensuring equitable access to high-quality schools for all students, regardless of their background, is a critical concern. Additionally, effective oversight and accountability mechanisms are necessary to ensure that all schools, including charter and private schools, provide a high standard of education. Balancing choice with equity and accountability is essential for the success of school choice initiatives.
Assessment and Accountability
A common phrase used when discussing education reform is “every student counts.” We can invert that belief and also contend that every student’s progress should be counted.
Assessments and accountability systems are essential for measuring student progress and ensuring that schools are meeting educational standards. Standardized testing, while often controversial, is a common tool used to gauge student achievement and identify areas in need of improvement.
Accountability measures, such as school report cards and performance-based funding, often take these test results into account, aiming to hold schools and educators responsible for student outcomes. Intervention strategies are then implemented for low-performing schools. This ideally ensures that all students receive a high-quality education and that schools are continuously working to improve student achievement.
Effective accountability systems balance the need for accountability with the provision of support for schools and educators. High-stakes testing and punitive measures alone do not sufficiently drive meaningful improvement. Instead, accountability systems should couple with targeted support — professional development, resources, and technical assistance — to help schools and educators succeed.
The use of assessments in education reform is not without challenges. Critics argue that an overemphasis on standardized testing can lead to a narrow focus on test preparation, detracting from a well-rounded education.
This overemphasis, “teaching to the test,” creates an unhealthy pressure and stress for both students and educators. To address these challenges, education reform efforts should promote a balanced approach to assessment that includes multiple measures of student learning and growth.
At the Education Revolution Association, we call this “teaching to the test of life.”
Technology Integration
The integration of technology in education has been a major focus of recent reform efforts. This crucial component has the potential to transform both learning and teaching.
Effective use can personalize learning, provide access to a wealth of resources, and prepare students for the digital age. Initiatives like 1:1 device programs, online learning platforms, and digital literacy curricula aim to enhance the learning experience and bridge the digital divide. Technology can also facilitate innovative instructional practices and support the development of 21st-century skills, such as critical thinking, collaboration, and digital literacy.
Digital tools like learning management systems (LMS), educational apps, and online resources play a significant role in technology integration. These provide students with interactive and engaging learning experiences, enable personalized instruction, and support differentiated learning. Additionally, digital platforms can facilitate collaboration and communication among students, teachers, and parents.
Effective technology integration requires educator proficiency both in using digital tools and incorporating them into their teaching practices. Ongoing training and support are essential for educators to effectively leverage these tools in the classroom. New professional development programs focus on this integration, helping teachers build their digital skills, explore new instructional strategies, and stay current with emerging technologies.
Ensuring equitable access to technology is a critical consideration in education reform. The digital divide, the gap between those who do and do not have access to technology, exacerbates existing educational inequalities. Education reform efforts must address issues of access by providing devices, internet connectivity, and digital literacy training to all students — particularly those in underserved communities.
While technology offers many benefits, it also presents challenges. Ensuring data privacy and security, addressing screen time concerns, and providing adequate technical support are important considerations in technology integration. Additionally, technology should be viewed as a tool to enhance learning, not as a replacement for effective teaching practices. Balancing the use of technology with traditional instructional methods is essential for creating a holistic and effective education system.
The Significance of Education Reform
The world is changing, and schooling needs to change with it.
Education reform is vital because it addresses the shortcomings and evolving needs of the educational system, ensuring that it meets the demands of a changing world. The significance of education reform lies in its potential to improve student outcomes, promote equity, and prepare students for the future. Let’s explore why education reform matters and how each key component contributes to these goals.
Promoting Equity and Social Justice
One of the most significant aspects of education reform is its potential to promote equity and social justice. By addressing disparities in access to high-quality education, reform efforts can help to level the playing field for students from different socioeconomic backgrounds. This can then lead to greater social mobility for students following their education and overall lead to a more equitable society.
Preparing Students for the Future
Education reform is essential for preparing students to succeed in an ever-changing world. The rapid pace of technological advancement and the evolving job market require students to possess a diverse set of skills, including critical thinking, problem-solving, and digital literacy. However, with fewer students choosing to pursue a college degree, education reform must also address alternative career paths. Reform initiatives that focus on updating curricula, integrating technology, and fostering innovative teaching practices are crucial for equipping students with the skills they need to thrive in the 21st century.
Fostering Civic Engagement and Democracy
Education plays a vital role in fostering civic engagement and strengthening democracy. Reform efforts that emphasize critical thinking, civic education, and media literacy can help students become informed and active citizens. By providing students with the knowledge and skills to participate in democratic processes, education reform can contribute to the development of a more engaged and informed group of voters.
Conclusion
By focusing on key components such as curriculum standards, teacher development, school choice, assessments and school accountability, and technology integration, education reform aims to create a more equitable, effective, and future-ready education system. Each component is crucial in shaping a robust and inclusive education system that prepares students for 21st century success.
As societies continue to evolve, education reform will remain vital in shaping the minds and futures of generations to come. By staying committed to the principles of equity, innovation, and excellence, education reform can help to build a brighter and more just future for all.
Will education ever be truly and fully reformed? Likely not, and it shouldn’t be. As our society grows and grapples with new challenges, schools need to evolve too. Teacher training will constantly improve. School choice will take on new looks, with broader — and perhaps more personalized — options. Students’ needs will change, and schools will need to change to meet them.
What are your thoughts on education reform? What most needs to change in schools today? In what ways will schools need to transform over the next decade? We want to hear your thoughts. Get in touch with the ERA team, and to join us in our efforts to prepare every student for life.
References
- Goertz, Margaret (1995). Studies of Education Reform: Systemic Reform U.S. of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement, Office of Reform Assistance and Dissemination. Pp i-ii ISBN 0-16-048866-4. OCLC 36672303 ↩︎
- U.S. Department of Education. (n.d.-a). Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA). Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) | U.S. Department of Education. https://www.ed.gov/essa ↩︎
- Common Core Standards. Common Core State Standards Initiative | Frequently Asked Questions. (2010, June 10). https://www.thecorestandards.org/resources/frequently-asked-questions/ ↩︎
- U.S. Department of Education. (n.d.). No Child Left Behind Act. ED.gov. https://www2.ed.gov/nclb/landing.jhtml ↩︎
- DeLollis, Barbara. (2021, November 16). What is a Magnet School? https://www.usnews.com/education/k12/articles/what-is-a-magnet-school ↩︎
Looking for Something More?
The Education Revolution Association is always ready to learn — we're obsessed with insights into American education! Is there an article topic you'd like to see us explore? A deep dive you just can't seem to find anywhere else? Let us know at our contact page!
Share Your Thoughts